FINA Committee Report
If you have any questions or comments regarding the accessibility of this publication, please contact us at accessible@parl.gc.ca.
DEPOLITICIZATION OF Supplementary Opinion of the Progressive Conservative Party In June 2000, the Liberal government introduced legislation and released guidelines dealing with prospective bank mergers in Canada. These measures would establish a framework with which bank mergers would be considered. Banks would file an extensive application outlining their merger proposal along with a Public Interest Impact Assessment statement (PIIA). The merger application would be subject to a very thorough review by the Competition Bureau. The Office of the Superintendent of Financial Institutions (OSFI) would review the prudential soundness of the merger. The House of Commons Finance Committee and the Senate Committee on Banking, Trade and Commerce would then conduct public hearings and summon the merging entities as witnesses in order to determine whether the merger is in the ‘public interest.’ The PIIA would serve as a key indicator. The Minister of Finance, in October 2002, surprised the markets when he asked the committees to hold special hearings in order to first clarify somehow what the government itself meant by its own phrase ‘public interest.’ If the government did not know what the phrase ‘public interest’ meant, maybe they should not have used it. The timing of this “public interest reference” was most curious inasmuch as it came scant days after the Prime Minister reportedly overruled his own Finance Minister and scotched merger proposals between the Bank of Nova Scotia and the Bank of Montreal, as well as between Manulife and the CIBC. The timing clearly showed that this was nothing more than another delaying tactic used by a government that is politically scared to death of bank mergers and is stifling the growth of a sector vital to the Canadian economy. We believe this is simply foot-dragging foot-dragging that will continue because this is a government that doesn’t have the courage to make a difficult decision even if it is in the best interest of the country. Ostensibly, after this Committee tables this Report, the government should be prepared to accept merger applications. However, whether this government will still be adverse to bank mergers remains to be seen.
It is the Finance Minister, as the person with the final say as to whether banks will be allowed to merge (or the prime minister in some governments), who should come before the Finance Committee to publicly state on record why a particular bank merger was accepted or denied. This would further help to depoliticize the bank merger process. That the Minister of Finance respond to this Report within 30 days. That the Minister of Finance appear before the Finance Committee to justify any decision on a proposed merger whether it be a denial or an approval. The Progressive Conservative Party calls on the Liberal government to stop delaying and to stop playing politics with this very important issue; failing to do so will further disrupt the ability of Canada’s financial institutions to develop and execute sound business strategies that will allow them to grow and expand, creating opportunity and prosperity for Canadians. Scott Brison, M.P. |